New Homes For Sale In Pine Island, FL

More About Pine Island

Living on Pine Island, FL

Tranquil, Nature-First Lifestyle

Pine Island stands out as the largest island along Florida’s Gulf Coast, distinguished by its mangrove-lined shores and rural charm rather than sun-drenched beaches. It’s an ideal escape for anyone seeking a quieter, slower-paced life away from urban hustle.

Strong Sense of Community & Culture

The island’s small–town atmosphere—free of traffic lights and marked by agriculture, fruit orchards, and a close-knit vibe—is a key part of its appeal. Matlacha, known as an “artist’s village,” adds a vibrant cultural layer with its colorful galleries, shops, and creative spirit. Community events like MangoMania, Pine Island Art Show, and the Garden Gala bring neighbors together in celebration and connection.

Outdoor Recreation

From kayaking, fishing, boating, to exploring aquatic preserves, Pine Island delivers abundant outdoor fun. The island also features multiple nature preserves—like Little Pine Island and the Matlacha Pass National Wildlife Refuge—where wildlife such as ospreys, spoonbills, and egrets thrive. Plus, you can dive into the area’s heritage at Pinseland’s Randell Research Center or the Calusa Heritage Trail.

Affordable Living with Coastal Perks

Compared to the Florida average, Pine Island offers a lower cost of living—about 7% less—with median home costs somewhat cheaper too. The pace and quality of life attract retirees and families looking for more space and warmth in a budget-conscious way.

A Break from City Living

Cited by residents as “the perfect place to escape the hustle and bustle of city life,” Pine Island’s beauty, friendly vibe, and relaxed pace make it an inviting place to call home

If you’re drawn to:

A peaceful, nature-driven lifestyle
Close community bonds and village charm
Outdoor recreation like fishing, kayaking, and wildlife viewing
A creative or relaxed pace of life
More affordable coastal living

…then Pine Island could be your dream home.

If the location of these communities is not your ideal location, Maronda Homes is also building: